|
PONTIFICAL CHANCERY On Authority, Conscience, and the Dignity of the Human Person Across the centuries, human societies have risen and fallen not only by the strength of their armies or the wealth of their treasuries, but by the moral character of those who exercise authority and of those who obey it. Authority, in its proper form, is a gift entrusted by God for the protection of life, the preservation of order, and the service of the common good. It is neither self-originating nor self-justifying. It exists only insofar as it remains oriented toward justice, restraint, and the dignity of the human person. History teaches a sobering lesson: when authority forgets its limits, and when obedience forgets its conscience, the result is not order and stability, but harm and violence clothed in procedure. Obedience is a virtue only when it remains bound to moral truth. Detached from conscience, obedience becomes mere compliance. Compliance, when unexamined, becomes a pathway by which ordinary people participate in extraordinary wrongs. No law, no command, no institution absolves a person from the responsibility to discern whether an action serves justice or undermines it before God and neighbor. To say “I was only following orders” has never healed a wound, restored a life, or justified an injustice. The doctrine of the faith is clear that each person remains morally accountable not only for what they intend, but for what they enable. Power tempts not only rulers, but systems. Then, systems, once untethered from moral restraint, tend to reward efficiency over wisdom, order over mercy, and loyalty over truth. When fear is cultivated as a tool of governance, compassion comes to be portrayed as weakness. Restraint in turn is mocked as betrayal, and cruelty begins to appear a so-called necessity. In such climates, cruelty often appears ordinary, and conscience is dismissed as inconvenience. Yet no society is strengthened by the erosion of its moral foundations. Authority that relies on intimidation rather than legitimacy eventually consumes itself. Institutions are judged not by their declarations, but by their practices. Those who serve within them, whether in uniform, office, or administration, do not cease to be moral agents when they assume a role. To carry out harm while claiming neutrality is not neutrality; it is moral abdication. To enforce injustice while claiming legality is not lawfulness; it is moral evasion. The measure of an institution’s integrity is found in whether it permits, protects, and even honors those who refuse to act against conscience. One of the great moral dangers of any age is the temptation to outsource responsibility, i.e., to surrender judgment upward, to systems, or to ideology. Yet, conscience cannot be delegated. Human dignity cannot be compartmentalized. Moral responsibility cannot be automated. Whenever a person is reduced to a category, a statistic, or an obstacle, something essential has already been lost, both in the victim and in the one who consents to such reduction. We therefore call all people, especially those entrusted with authority, to renewed vigilance of the heart. Let leaders remember that they are stewards, not masters. Let servants of institutions remember that loyalty does not require moral blindness. Let citizens remember that order without justice is merely organized disorder. Above all, let us resist the ancient temptation to believe that “our side” is exempt from moral scrutiny. No tradition, no nation, no cause is purified by abandoning the dignity of the human person. The health of a society is revealed not in moments of triumph, but in moments of strain, when fear tempts us to surrender principle for the illusion of control. May we choose instead the harder path: the path of conscience over convenience, of restraint over domination, and of moral courage over silent compliance. For it is not power that preserves civilization, but the disciplined conscience of those who wield it. May wisdom guide us. May humility restrain us. And may we never forget that every human being stands before God not as an instrument, but as a person entrusted to our care. Радислав Пп. I
[Chancery] [Curia]
|
