Independent Catholic Church International and Multinational Orthodoxy

THE LEGACY OF THE
INDEPENDENT CATHOLIC CHURCH INTERNATIONAL,
MULTINATIONAL ORTHODOXY,
AND THE
FORMER ANGLICAN DIOCESE OF THE SOUTHWEST

Released by St. George Seminary Press in 2023, Journey of Faith: The Apostolic See of Saints Stephen and Mark, by Rutherford I is a history of the present See and its people - those who went before us, laying the groundwork over the last decades and past centuries, and those who keep the faith today.

Patriarch Antonius (Aneed), a key figure in the Byzantine Apostolic Succession of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church, shown here in the back row, second from right, in a photograph with Pope Saint Pius X, Bishop of Rome (seated front centre) and Cyril VIII (Geha), Patriarchate of the Greek/Melkite Catholic Church (seated next to Pius X).

Among the most important historical elements that the Diocese of Rome-Ruthenia (United Roman-Ruthenian Church) succeeds is the Independent Catholic Church International. That Patriarchal and Apostolic See was formed in 1981 as the unification of various Old Catholic and traditional Anglican churches and also brought them together with significant Apostolic lineage of and affiliation with the Eastern Rite Christian Churches. It was led first by H.E. Most Rev. Peter Wayne Goodrich as Primate. Then H.E. Most Rev. Robert Vincent Bernard Dawe, previously the church's international legate, became Primate in 1983. Several churches around the world today are in the Apostolic Succession via the Independent Catholic Church International.

Among those Apostolic descendants is the Diocese and Catholicate of Rome-Ruthenia, the senior jurisdiction of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church. It realises the dream of unified western-eastern Christianity envisioned by Archbishop Dawe and other predecessors and maintains its own distinct liturgy built upon the 1600-year-old Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom with elements of the Roman Tridentine Rite. In addition, the Catholicate maintains several important documents and records of the late Archbishop Dawe in its Pontifical Apostolic Library.

A book entitled The Wandering Bishops from the
personal collection of Archbishop Dawe, donated to and maintained
by the Stephenian Archives of the Apostolic See.

Additionally, even though it is not formally a member of other ecclesial bodies, the Catholicate and entire United Roman-Ruthenian Church has historical communion and shared heritage with the Anglican Communion and the Philippine Independent Church (also known as the Philippine Independent Catholic Church) via the historic First Chair of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church, as Bishop of the Southwest, located at St. Chad's Cathedral. Both are in turn in communion with the Old Catholic See of Utrecht.

Saint Edwin Caudill (His Grace Howard Edwin Caudill) was consecrated by Macario V. Ga, Supreme Pontiff (Bishop) of the Philippine Independent Church, and Bishops Frank Benning and John Hamers. 21 October 1993, Holy Cross Polish National Catholic Church, Brooklyn, New York. The Diocese of the Southwest was for a time part of a communion known as The Anglican Church, Inc. It had previously been part of the Anglican Catholic Church, and its first bishop was the Rt. Rev. Robert Harvey. Bishop Caudill was consecrated as the Coadjutor for the diocese in 1983 and then became the Bishop Ordinary upon Bishop Harvey's resignation in 1984. In 1983, the Anglican Church, Inc. entered into a communion with the American Episcopal Church (distinct from the Protestant Episcopal Church of the United States), which provied two co-consecrators for Bishop Caudill. The American Episcopal Church had also entered into a communion agreement with the with the Diocese of Amritsar, of the former Church of India, Pakistan, Burma and Ceylon, the automous province of the Anglican Church of England in India. At the time, the joint leadership of the Anglican Church, Inc. and the American Episcopal Church included the following Bishops: Anthony F.M. Clavier, Primate, John M. Hamers, H. Edwin Caudill, Frank H. Benning, Walter H. Grundorf, G. Raymond Hanlan, and Robert C. Harvey. There were approximately 74 parishes and around 5000 members.

In the Southwest Diocese, Saint Edwin was succeeded by Bishop Wayne Ellis (see newsletter transcripts) The remnants of Saint Edwin's See, the Diocese of the Southwest, after suffering a schism, became part of the Apostolic Communion of Anglican Churches in 2008. This included the Very Rev. Dean John Mark Vornholt, who returned in 2009, recognizing it as the authentic continuation of the Diocese of the Southwest in which he had previously served under Bishop Caudill. The new Bishop of the Southwest was the Vicar-General of the Apostolic Communion of Anglican Churches. He was subsequently succeeded by H.H. Bishop Rutherford I Johnson of Rome-Ruthenia (then Archbishop Johnson), at which point it became a Metropolitan See. Thereafter its territorial boundaries changed, and it was known as the Patriarchal See of St. Stephen and Coadjutorship of Rome.

Bishop Rutherford Johnson-Roma-Rus' visiting the Cathedral of St. Chad in San Antonio, Texas, USA as a guest of church clergy and staff. The church of St. Chad houses the throne that is recognised as the historic First Chair of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church (see above). It is also the cathedral of his predecessor, Bishop Edwin Caudill, as Bishop of the Southwest, later renamed the See of St. Stephen and subsequently became part of the Apostolic See of Sts. Stephen and Mark.

Very Rev. Dean John Mark Vornholt (1934-2010)
Dean to the Metropolitan of the Southwest

The following is one of several pastoral letters contributed by Dean Vornholt while serving as Dean to the Metropolitan of the Southwest (then-Archbishop Johnson). These letters were published under the title of "Papa Doc's Ponderings." (One of the Dean's former parishioners called him "Papa John," and when he earned a doctorate, he began calling him "Papa Doc.") The letters had a certain colloquial style that nevertheless was filled with meaning.

Papa Doc's Ponderings

CLERICAL CHOLER

The world will little note nor long remember, but Sunday morning only one of two retired priests attending nondenominational First Evangelical Church in Memphis wore clericals. Fr. Robertson Eppes, a longtime friend and former rector of All Saints, Memphis, did. I didn’t as I occupied a pew next to my wife, kids and grandkids (my son-in-law, in fact, is an elder and my daughter leads a Bible study)

First Evan has long welcomed me. I officiated at my daughter’s marriage there, using the 1928 BCP. A former pastor, Ronnie Stevens, used to joke that seeing Rob+ and I in the congregation was good advertising. His successor, Howard Clark, allowed Anglican Common Cause to use the fellowship hall for a regional assembly.

So my rationale in wearing civvies had nothing to do with First Evan but a lot to do with what’s been happening in The Episcopal Church (formerly known as PECUSA) and in the Diocese of West Tennessee in particular.

Prior to ordination I had a long and honorable history in the Diocese of Tennessee and its successor, having served at St. Andrew’s, Harriman, as senior warden, lay reader and delegate to convention; St. Michael’s, Knoxville, during a year of graduate school at UTK; Christ Church, Chattanooga, during a year as visiting professor at UTC (a much more conservative +Don Johnson was then rector); and, eventually, Good Shepherd, Memphis, as vestryman and convention delegate.

Looking back, I see a common thread—these were all either Anglo-Catholic or Prayer Book Catholic parishes largely isolated from PECUSA’s creeping national liberalism. Bishops tended to leave them alone....

Then in 1987, through a chance (miraculous?) reconnection with +Ed Caudill, under whom I read for Holy Orders more than 20 years earlier in the Diocese of Oklahoma, I completed the canonical exams and was ordained deacon and priest in the Anglican Diocese of the Southwest, a Continuing Church body in which he had been made Bishop Ordinary following his consecration in the undisputed Chambers/ Denver succession.

Yesterday I decided I didn’t want to answer any more questions from First Evan’ers who identified me with the Diocese of West Tennessee and its policies/polity. It seemed too much like guilt by association.... So I wore civvies there for the first time in more than 20 years, and will continue to do so.

Strangely I’m reminded about somewhat similar confusion a half-century when my late mother mentioned, “I see where some offshoot of your church is talking about merging with mine” (she was then a United Methodist and growing up and serving as a pastor’s wife in the old Evangelical & Reformed Church).

I had a hard time explaining to her that St. Matthew’s, Bloomington, IL, was in fact a parish of the Protestant Episcopal Church. “Ach, no,” she said, referring to the smells and bells, confessional booth and other appurtenances common in the Biretta Belt of the upper Midwest, in which Nashotah House was referred to as “The One True Seminary of the Church” (all one word).

So there you have it, for what it’s worth! “Hier stehe ich, ich kann nicht anders “ as Luther said—“Here I stand, I can do no other.”

Part of the page for Papa Doc's Pondering on the original website of the Metropolitan Archdiocese of the Southwest.

Upon the death of Dean Vornholt in 2010, Bishop Rutherford I (then-Archbishop Johnson) gave the following statement:

Dear Brethren,

It was with great sadness that I learned of the death of the Very Reverend John Vornholt, Dean Emeritus of the Archdiocese of the Southwest and my adviser. He was not only a true priest who saw, believed, and understood the real mission of the clergy, he was a devoted family man and kind gentleman with his own unique humor. This you can see in his periodic writings known as "Papa Doc's Ponderings."

Dean Vornholt was, earlier in the history of the Archdiocese, Dean of the St. George Theological Seminary. In more recent times, he helped us greatly in our period of great renewal. Indeed, I credit a large portion of our success to his advice and support.

Though retired, he recently told me that if his health were better, he was again motivated to start a new parish. It was a great compliment to the wonderful things happening in the Archdiocese, and I hope he truly understood that those wonderful things were thanks in large part to him. It is quite sad that he was too sick to start that parish.

Dean Vornholt's illness was no secret to his family and friends, and to those of us who worked closely with him in the church. Yet, he kept on, doing what he could to help our revival and growth. On the academic front, our seminary launched a new academic journal, with him as Editor-in-Chief. The list of his good work even in his last years is impressive.

Many prayers and masses were said for his recovery. Yet, we do not seek ever to bend the outcome to our will, but rather yield to the will of God. The Almighty Father chose to call home his ever-faithful servant and devoted priest. We now pray for the repose of his soul. He will be sorely missed, but we look forward to a heavenly reunion.

The Stephenian Archives (the archives of the Apostolic See of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church) and the Pontifical Apostolic Library maintain extensive records pertaining to the history of the former Anglican Diocese of the Southwest, the Philippine Independent Catholic Church, and the Independent Catholic Church International and their relationship to the modern United Roman-Ruthenian Church. Just a few of those documents, excerpts, and fragments are provided by the Pontifical Apostolic Library below in the interest of preservation of history and the legacy of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church.

Attestation of communion with the Anglican Communion
via the First Chair of the Catholicate (Anglican Diocese of the Southwest).

Letter from Archbishop Dawe regarding the Synod of the
Independent Catholic Church International and the
election of its Primate.

Letter acknowledging affiliation with the Episcopal Synod of America
on the Diocese of the Southwest (later the Diocese of Rome-Ruthenia, United Roman-Ruthenian Church) under Bishop H. Edwin Caudill

Letter from the Very Reverend John Vornholt, here as Curate of
the Parish of the Nativity, later as Dean to the Metropolitan
Archbishop of the Southwest (later H.H. Rutherford I)

The Old Roman Catholic Apostolic heritage of the Catholicate also historically enjoyed an intercommunion with the ancient Orthodox Patriarchal Sees of Antioch and Alexandria, the first See of the Apostle Peter and the second See of the Apostle Mark respectively. These agreements were achieved by Archbishop Arnold Harris Mathew. The intercommunion with Antioch was signed on 5 August 1911, and the intercommunion with Alexandria was signed the following year.

The following is the text of a letter to Archbishop Mathew on behalf of the Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Antioch, Gregory IV:

These agreements in practical terms have lapsed, but they have never been rescinded. They remain an important and valued part of the heritage of the entire United Roman-Ruthenian Church. Combined with other historic agreements, they solidify the historic and current canonical status of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church.

The Church's Orthodox heritage also includes the American Orthodox Catholic Church (via Prince-Abbots Emond I and Edmond II of San Luigi), the Catholicate of the West (via Mar Georgius I), and the African Orthodox Church (via Alexander I). The United Roman-Ruthenian Church's Russian Orthodox succession also comes from Abdullah Aftimios Ofiesh, consecrated in the Russian Orthodox Church. He was founder of the American Orthodox Catholic Church. Born in Lebanon, he was commissioned to found an English-speaking jurisdiction of the Russian Orthodox Church in the United States. He married, with the intent to abolish the requirement of a celibate episcopacy.

Mar Ioannes and Mar Georgius, Catholicos of the West, from whom the
United Roman-Ruthenian Church descends in Apostolic Succession and heritage.

Excerpts of the concordat establishing the American Concordat Exarchate of America and Federation of Independent Catholic and Orthodox Churches, an ecclesiastical federation from which the United Roman-Ruthenian Church descends. Among the signers, as seen in the copies above, are Archbishop Wadle, Patriarch Antonius Joseph, and Archbishop Edgar Ramon Verostek (North American Old Roman Catholic Church), all of whom are in the Apostolic Succession of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church.

Archbishop Lowell Paul Wadle, Primate of the American Catholic Church,
Apostolic Episcopal Church, and Apostolic Catholic Church.

Edmond I, Prince-Abbot of San Luigi

Apostolic and Temporal Succession of Rutherford I. Pontifical Georgian Press. 2024.
Bartlett, R. The Making of Europe: Conquest, Colonization and Cultural Change 950-1350. Princeton University Press. 1993.
Binns, J. An Introduction to the Christian Orthodox Churches. Cambridge University Press. 2002.
Chalandon, F. Histoire de la domination normande en Italie et en Sicile. A. Picard. 1907.
Deffenbaugh v. Röm-Frankfurt, Ed. Almanac of Würzburg. Pontifical Georgian Press. 2016-2024.
Dimnik, M. The Dynasty of Chernigov, 1146–1246. Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies. 2004.
Erickson, J. The Challenge of Our Past: Essays in Orthodox Church History and Canon Law. St. Vladimir's Seminary Press. 1991.
Fennell, J. The Crisis of Medieval Russia, 1200-1304. Longman. 1983.
Franklin, S., Shepard, J. The Emergence of Rus 750-1200. Longman. 1996.
Gavaldá y Castro, Rubén and Arnaldo I. A. Miranda Tumbarello. Fons Honorum: compendio de Derecho Nobiliario Europeo y Americano. Instituto Heraldico de Buenos Aires. 2015.
Genealogy of the House of Johnson-Roma-Rus’. Pontifical Georgian Press. 2024.
Ghisalberti, A. M. Alberico di Ivrea: Signore del Piemonte. Tipografia sociale. 1962.
Heritage and Ecclesiastical Titles in the United Roman-Ruthenian Church. Il Nunzio Romano-Ruteno. 2023.
Herrin, J. The Formation of Christendom. Princeton University Press. 1989.
Inside the Unique Governance of the United Roman-Ruthenian Church. Il Nunzio Romano-Ruteno. 2023.
Logan, D. F. A History of the Church in the Middle Ages. Routledge. 1992.
Magocsi, P. R. A History of Ukraine. University of Toronto Press. 1996.
Martin, J. Medieval Russia, 980-1584. Cambridge University Press. 1995.
McKitterick, R. The Frankish Kingdoms under the Carolingians, 751–987. Longman. 1983.
Meyendorff, J. Imperial Unity and Christian Divisions: The Church 450-680 A.D. St Vladimir’s Seminary Press. 1989.
Ostrogorsky, G. History of the Byzantine State. Rutgers University Press. 1969.
Papadakis, A. The Christian East and the Rise of the Papacy. St Vladimir’s Seminary Press. 1994.
Runciman, S. Byzantine Civilization. Cambridge University Press. 1933.
Rutherford I. Journey of Faith. Pontifical Georgian Press. 2022.
Setton, K. M. The Papacy and the Levant (1204-1571). American Philosophical Society. 1976.
Thomson, F. J. The Reception of Byzantine Culture in Mediaeval Russia. Variorum. 1999.
Ware, T. The Orthodox Church. Penguin Books link. 1997.
Wickham, C. The Inheritance of Rome: A History of Europe from 400 to 1000. Penguin Books. 2009.